Mukto-Mona is against all type of Fundamentalism

By Biplab Pal
 

 

On Sat Dec 4, 2004,  Mr. Mohiuddin wrote the following piece in MM (message# 21476): 

Why Mukto-Mona is helping the campaign against America's fastest religion Islam? What is their intention? Why this forum is campaigning against Islam only? Who pays for their campaign? Why Mukto-Mona is 'hesitant to criticize World's other major religions ? Interestingly anti-Prophet writings are distributed free, Why? who pays for such e-book? I think it's time for the concerned Muslim Americans to rise and create their own forum to answer their anti-Islamic tirade.

-Mohiuddin

Following is my response: 

Why Mukto-Mona is helping the campaign against America's fastest religion Islam?

US does not conduct any religious census. Therefore, growth of Islam in USA is a myth propagated by Islamists. After 9/11, in all possibilities, it is the fastest declining religion in USA because I can see, more and more Muslim youths are declining Islam. However, there is not data to support or oppose this view.

 

What is their intention?

So that the fundamentalists like you on the earth can be made rational....so that people like you does not turn into an Islamic terrorist. Unfortunately Islam contains more fundamentalists than any other faith.

 

Why this forum is campaigning against Islam only? Who pays for their campaign?

I wrote more against Hinduism than Islam in this forum. So, obviously you don't read this website. Your assessment can not be counted unless you read the website.

 

Why Mukto Mona is 'hesitan't to criticize World's other major religions?

Muktomona is criticizing all religions. Your statement proves you don't read Muktomona.

 

Interestingly anti-Prophet writings are distributed free, Why? who pays for such ebook?

Very unfortunately e-book is not that costly. I will be willing to pay for such books because prophet Mohammad or any other prophet caused more trouble to the world than anybody I can think of.

 

I think it's time for the concerned Muslim Americans to rise and create their own forum to answer their anti-Islamic tirade.

You have plenty of websites to do that. However, anti-Muslim website of Ali Sina, www.faithfreedom.org  is more popular than any of the other. www.faithfreedom.com  tried to oppose Ali Sina.

But you see nobody except fundamentalists/terrorists reads pro-Islamic website. On the other hand, Muktomona gives you the opportunity to answer anti-Islamic tirade. You have right to defend your faith here. Why don't you do that in Mukto-mona.

You have seen another Hindu Fundamentalist Vir, tried to defend his faith and Avijit replied to him. If you are so sure, Islam is so great, why don't you prove logically? Avijit has given you the opportunity.

So far what I have understood reading about Mohammad's life and Qouran is very simple:

"He was an intelligent & materialistic man and was also a good man in early age. As his power has grown up, he become more and more intolerant and his teaching transformed into another standard format of religious oppression & intolerance. Also, with power, his sexual libido become irresistible and he married a lot of women from other tribes whom he forced to follow his religion"

Just disprove it with history/geography/anything you want...

-Biplab

December 6, 2004

 

[Mukto-mona] [Articles] [Recent Debate] [Special Event ] [Moderators] [Forum]