“Koran on Mountain”: Rebuttal to Islamic hypocrisy


By Syed Kamran Mirza




Readers you please check any pure Islamic site, to your surprise, you will come up with the barrages of Islamic scientific claims in the Holy Quran.  I call them “Budoo science” of Arab Bedouin Allah. Maurice Bucailee by his utter dishonesty had created this utopia of Islamic science which again made these Islamists crazy and hungry for Quranic science only to keep gullible Muslims in the darkness. Below is my response to such wishful Quranic science about Allah’s mountain creation.


The dishonest and utterly hypocritical Islamist (author of the article) pointed out two benefits out of Allah’s mountain on earth. These are:


1.      Mountain is like peg.

2.      Mountain works as stabilizers for the earth.


Fact of the matter is mountain is neither a peg nor it prevents shaking of the earth. There could be nothing bigger lies than this claim. The above claims are utterly false and heinously nonsense. Both are scientifically wrong and simply ludicrous. Let us examine the Quranic verses about mountain.


Why Mountains were created(?):


In the following verses, Quran claims that mountains were set on the earth so that the earth never can shake when human being dwelt in it.


(Quran- 21:31): And We have set on earth firm mountains, lest it should shake with them.


(Quran-16:15):  And he has cast the earth firm mountains lest it shake with you… 


(Quran-31:10):  He created the heavens without supports that you can see, and has cast onto the earth firm mountains lest it shake with you…


It is clearly understood that Quranic author was completely ignorant about the geological reasoning for existence of mountains. He believed that this Earth is like flat platform where mankind resides. He also saw that mountains are huge and heavy which have been placed on the earth surface like paper weights or paper stone!  So, He (Allah) thought mountains actually prevent Shaking (Earthquake) of the earth.  Fact is, this particular reasoning for existence of mountains is a direct contradiction with modern geological knowledge.

      Ancient people viewed mountains as pegs.  This is just stupid and utter ignorance about the very creation of mountain. Mountains have pegged the earth with what?  We all know why how and where a peg is being used. Pegs are normally used to fix something against a firm support. We hang pictures/portrait in our drawing room using pegs. Tents are fixed using pegs so that they stand firm and so on. But mountains pegged the earth with what object?  Ancient people thought in the similar way, Omnipotent God created mountain to fix earth from shaking/moving/rotating.  Thats why all in their scriptures mountains are described as pegs. Hindu scripture also have the same myth. Here is what RIK VEDA (Hindu Scripture) told many thousand years before generating Quran on earth.

"Sabita made this Earth fixed by different devices (like hills and mountains) and sustains sky without pillars so that it does not move" [RIK VEDA]

Now, should the mankind accept Hindu science, rather than Islamic science, as they brought that scientific miracle of “mountain” much earlier than Allah?

How mountain is formed?

Geology teaches us that movement of tectonic plates, volcanic force or earthquake itself causes mountains to be formed. Plate Tectonic changes are responsible for terrestrial ocean basins continents or mountains formation. Earthquake and volcanic eruptions creating pressure to compress Earth’s crustal rocks to form mountains. Fault zones tend be the source of earthquake. And tectonic plate movements shape continents, form mountains and generate the volcanism that continually renews the ocean floors. If some crustal plates are separating or rifting by the formation of a new oceanic crust, there must be other places on the planet where plates are crunching together. At such boundaries—tectonic plates can collide which can lift up the land to make a giant mountain.

The highest mountain, like Himalayan range was formed when the Indian plate collided with the Asian plate around 250 million years ago. It is believed that India was connected with Antarctica and Australia about 300 million years ago. Then the plate separated and the Indian continent started drifting northwards. When it collided with the Asian plate the sea level rose and the mountain range formed from the bottom of the sea. The evidence is that high at the top of Himalayan the geologists have discovered fossils of sea creatures. The other truth is that the Himalayan is the youngest mountain range in the world. It is not finished yet--the height of Himalayan Mountain peaks are still raising. The question of providing stability does not arise at all.

Truth of the matter is, all mountains had been formed by shaking of this earth in the first place, and i.e. mountain could not be formed/born without severe shaking of this planet earth, period. Besides, we know very well that, every year several dozens of earthquakes happen on earth. Then what is the result of Allah’s promise? Can we believe that, Mountains are there to prevent earthquake? Then why thousands of earthquakes happen every century?

I am sure this ridiculous “mountain story for stabilizing earth from shaking” is perhaps one of the lies of Dr. Maurice Bucaille revealed in his (in)famous book -"The Bible, the Qur'an and Science", which was comprehensively refuted by Dr. William Campbell in his "The Qur'an and the Bible in the Light of History & Science". 

Mountains are never viewed as the stabilizing factors. I never heard or read that any world famous geologist ever claimed that mountains help earth to stabilize or mountain prevents earth from moving/shaking. Actually Mountains are the source of earth’s shaking. Their formation caused and still causes the surface of the earth to shake. Where there are more mountains, there are more earthquakes and more shaking of the planet earth. Any country that has many mountains definitely have many volcanoes and volcanic eruptions normally give rise many earthquakes every year. Consider the earthquake zones of earth. Earthquakes happen 'all the time' and they are concentrated along specific zones, in which mountainous areas are also concentrated. Therefore, claims that mountains are firm and immovable is simply ridiculous and utter lie. Besides, mountains on earth are not proportionally or uniformly distributed every where, i. e. in some areas there are many mountains, on the other area there are no mountains at all.

The Earth itself is revolving about the Sun; Sun and its planets are revolving about our Milky Way galaxy; The Milky Way galaxy is again moving around the center of the Local Group of Galaxies.... etc. So mountains cannot be considered as "immoveable" as the whole universe is moving.

Besides, the planet Earth of ours is the result of billions of years of continuous evolutionary transformation. This planet earth has undergone series of geological change for hundreds of millions of years. There was time when all these continents were together and later they were separated from each other, perhaps that episode caused severe/terrible shaking of the earth. Himalayas were formed when the Indian subcontinent bumps against the Asian plate causing tremendous shaking of this earth. Then why Allah talked about the nonsense of creating mountain to prevent shaking of the earth? Did not the process of creation of Himalayas occur much after the original creation of this earth by merciful Allah?  Why did He lie with Prophet Muhammad that He (Allah) created mountains to prevent shaking of this earth?


How Islamists make science in Quran!

 When modern science and modern consensus tell us that shaking of the earth is directly related with the presence of mountains and volcanoes in that locality some wishful Islamists claim that actually mountains are there to stop shaking of earth! How is it possible? Let me tell you how it is possible. These so called Islamic intellectuals when dealing religion, Koran and Allah—they immediately lose their all intellects, common sense, and become Allah’s robot only to achieve their ludicrous lustrous life after death. They vow to protect Allah’s Koranic garbage at the cost of their civil and intellectual norms and they start talking all nonsense just to make Allah’s garbage some what meaningful to the readers. They even forget that their weird logic will not be able to convince anybody who is a sensible person and not blinded with faith. Yet they continue to do so only to get lustrous heaven and to save their skin from the hell fire!


This Islamist used some references which are all from (some other) blind-faith Islamists and some reference only to give structural description of mountains, such as pegging earth. Pegging earth with what? They are unable to give any reference that will talk about shaking or stabilizing earth due to mountain. Is there any world famous geologist who can claim that mountain can prevent shaking of the earth? I am sure no geologist can claim such a lie about mountain.


Finally, let me make my firm assertion that—mountains and volcanoes are the primary cause of shaking earth and mountains/volcanoes can never prevent earth’s shaking, period.





  1. Exploring Planetary Worlds: By David Morrison; Scientific American library; A division of HPHLP, New York. 1993.
  2. The World Book Encyclopedia: Volume 13; World Book, Inc. Chicago. London.  Sydney. Toronto.
  3. The Holy Qur’an, Translated by A. Yousuf Ali, Published by Amana Corporation, Brentwood, Maryland, 1983

[Mukto-mona] [Articles] [Recent Debate] [Special Event ] [Moderators] [Forum]