Re: Is Marxism (Communism) Scientific?

By Setara Hashem

E-mail: [email protected]   


Dear Reader,

Mr. Avijit has accused me of personal attack and advised me to concentrate on the subject of discussion. He considers capitalist and Islam basher are abusive words. My statement on which he made such allegation was as follow:- (1) M/S Avijit, Alamgir and Jahed claim to be humanist thinkers; (2) Mr. Avijit claims to be an atheist and well known Islam basher, is now blaming Soviet CP for putting ban on religious practice.

He imported the word capitalist and started blaming me. The word "capitalist" or "Islam basher" are not abusive words. I know the meaning of capitalist. Mr. Avijit belongs to middle class intellectual group. This group has two divisions. He pretends to be a pro people intellectual middle class, but his write-ups indicate otherwise. He has lots of write-up of bashing Islam in Mukhto Mona web site, which heats the sentiment of the people. In Hindu shastra, there is a proverb, " Three steps with a man becomes ideological friend". I think he has already given more then three steps with the enemy of toiling mass. As a well wisher I tried him at the beginning to stop writing against Islam, but he did not listen to me at that time. Now he is objecting the word "Islam basher".

It appears to me he has problem of differentiating of meaning of criticism and bashing along with so many other words. Religion is personal affairs, should not be brought under criticism or bashing along with holy books. These books are part and parcel of elements of history, should be looked in the light of social system, economical system and level of thinking of the people on the time of written of the books.

Mr. Avijit has also problem of identification of real enemy of the people. The real enemy of people of our time is religious traders and imperialism and theirs agents. In India Congress and CPI is opposite force, still CPI supported Congress to defeat greater enemy, BJP Jot, who are religious trader and imperialist friend. Same is the case with BD politics, left force and AL bear opposite ideology, but they coincide in secularism and 4 principles of Mukhtijoddho. So they are unitedly fighting against greater enemy of the people i.e. BNP Jot, who is religious trader and imperialist agent. US and Israeli foreign policy is the root case of present trouble of unilateral world. This force is now threat to civilization and humanity. If there was USSR, USA would not dare to attack Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem of the world is not Marxism or religion. So those who are hitting Marxism and religion at this juncture of time are not friends of the people. They are agents of evil axis. My pen will be harder against them.

Setara Hashem 
Mon May 17, 2004 5:46 am

Avijit Roy rebuts Setra Hashem again

Page: 1  2  3  4  5

[Mukto-mona] [Articles] [Recent Debate] [Special Event ] [Moderators] [Forum]